November 18, 2013
September 11, 2013
9/11
I submitted the following comment on 9/11 to the London Jewish Chronicle, which published a version of it in their September 4th issue:
The World Trade Center was an anchor for our neighborhood, a
north star to help one navigate the warrens of New York’s streets, a beacon for
all who could catch a glimpse of its twin towers. The date of its destruction is a similar
anchor to the calendar, a fixed point against which we measure our growth. As we gain distance from that day, pixelated
images and inchoate impressions have found a measure of coherence, hardened to
memory.
Following the attacks, we were faced with the daunting task
of rebuilding. Although we suffered no
significant physical damage, our collective sense of well-being and confidence were
shattered. The Museum family was spared
direct loss, but each member of the staff who witnessed the attack and its
aftermath was changed. I was in Berlin
on 9/11 at the opening of the Jewish Museum and returned Erev Rosh Hashanah to
find my apartment uninhabitable and my colleagues, each in their own way,
responding to their collective and individual traumas. I had
lunch with the Museum’s chairman, Robert Morgenthau, a week or so after my
return, and he told me to get the Museum open again as soon as possible. I responded that it would be difficult since
we were locked down by roadblocks and surrounded by armed guards. “I’ll take care of the roadblocks,” he said,
“you get the Museum cleaned and ready.” He also instructed me to continue with
our plans to build a major expansion to our building.
Although I did not voice them, I had many misgivings. It struck me as imprudent at that moment to
commit scores of millions of dollars to a major building effort in a grievously
wounded neighborhood, the future of which was uncertain. But I followed his instructions, and we
reopened the Museum on October 5th and broke ground for the
expansion in November.
Ours was the first new construction project in Lower
Manhattan following 9/11, and we were warmed by this distinction, which held a
particular resonance since our Core Exhibition focuses, in part, on the period
following the Holocaust, with its dramatic story of the rebirth of life and
community following great tragedy. There
were days when trucks conveying new steel for our construction mixed in traffic
with trucks transporting twisted relics of steel away from Ground Zero. This jarring juxtaposition in the noisy
street presented a potent metaphor for the continuity of life and the impulse
to rebuild.
Our new wing opened on the second anniversary of 9/11,
finally completing the original vision of the Museum, providing a magnificent
building permitting us to offer, finally, a full range of exhibitions and programming. Although more people can fit in my dining
room at home than visited us each day during the period immediately following our
reopening, visitation has since rebounded, and downtown is booming once again
with new amenities and the promise of a bright future. On the first Yahrzeit of 9/11 (23rd
of Elul), we opened a remarkably moving and inspiring exhibition about 9/11
focusing on our neighborhood and on the Jewish community, and we mark the
anniversary each year with a memorial candle in our lobby and a commemorative
program in our theater.
Since 9/11, we have experienced our share of natural
disasters – two hurricanes (Irene and Super Storm Sandy) and even a mild
earthquake. The disruption caused by
these events, and their undeniable emotional impact, reminded us all of that
September morning when the norms of everyday life were suddenly upturned, and
the stabilizing anchors of our lives were dislodged. But the waters subsided and the earth stopped
shaking, and we were left again to face a world that was so unalterably changed
12 years ago.
August 19, 2013
Jacques Vergès -- Klaus Barbie
Jacques Vergès |
The controversial French attorney, Jacques Vergès, died last week, and the news brought me immediately back to a chilly February evening in Paris. It was February 2007, and I was in Paris working on the documentary film, Elusive Justice. I arrived at Vergès's beautiful apartment a bit later than my colleagues, and the film's director, Jonathan Silvers, met me at the door and whispered, "He's the perfect Bond Villain," or words to that effect. Jonathan was right. Vergès was unlike anyone I had encountered before.
Elegant and sophisticated, somehow he did not square with what I had imagined. After all, Vergès had defended Klaus Barbie before the French courts and represented a virtual rogues gallery of other unsavory characters like Carlos the Jackal and Cambodia’s Khmer Rouge head of state, Khieu Samphan. I thought I was about to confront the devil, or, at least the devil's advocate, which was a nickname that had been applied to him. I was so convinced that I would have a fight with Vergès that we worked out a plan with the cameraman, Bobby Caccamise, to make sure he would catch both sides of the contretemps. No such thing transpired. Vergès was a perfect gentleman, who did not rise to my bait and answered every question with a pointed reserve that was at once seductive and intimidating.
Before entering his impressive office, which was decorated with tapestries and works of art from several continents, we had to pass through an anteroom containing one long table covered completely with a museum's worth of chessboards and chessmen. The message was clear.
Rat Line Memo |
The death of Jacques Vergès came nearly on the 30th anniversary of the release of the Justice Department's report on Klaus Barbie. In 1983, I was privileged to have been able to work on the Barbie Investigation, which was led by Allan A. Ryan, Jr., who had been my boss at the Office of Special Investigations. Allan was just about to leave OSI when the Barbie case broke, and he remained on as a special assistant to the Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal Division to conduct the investigation.
We broke new ground in this unusual effort. For the first time, we revealed how US Intelligence had employed former Nazis against the Soviets and we published a massive appendix with copies of original (although redacted) records. A major break in the investigation came when I discovered documents at the National Archives Records Center in Suitland, Maryland that revealed the existence of an escape route, known as the "Rat Line," which was used to evacuate Barbie (and many others) out of Europe.
The Barbie Report still makes interesting reading today ....
April 9, 2013
Kickstarter Campaign for the Auschwitz Jewish Center
Our Kickstarter Campaign for the Auschwitz Jewish Center's project to save the home of the last Jewish resident of Oswiecim (Auschwitz) is well underway. We just received our 50th contribution and crossed the $4000 mark. Please take a look at the project and give whatever you can to support it.
April 8, 2013
Annual Gathering of Remembrance
Photo: Melanie Einzig |
Here are the remarks that I delivered yesterday:
The cycle of the Jewish year has its rhythm. Sabbath
days, like a metronome mark the measures of the weeks. Holidays
and festivals give a cadence to the year, motifs and melodies that bring
meaning to our days. The cycle of a Jewish life has its rhythm as well, the
high notes of simchas – births and weddings – the dark chords of death and the
ritual of mourning. The cycle of our year has brought us again to this day and
to this place to carry out our sacred task.
In that place, we remember and we mourn what we have lost as
individuals and what we have lost as a community. Although it may be possible to identify our
personal losses and the losses that
befell our families and marred our communities, no one can possibly quantify
the vast potential that was denied our people and robbed from the world. We mourn a loss that grows in time as we
consider generations that were never born, creativity that was never expressed,
achievement that could never be realized.
In this place of solitude and community, we also honor those
who survived and demonstrated the power of the human spirit to recover and to
rebuild. Having witnessed the worst in the
human experience they found the best in themselves. The presence here today of so many survivors,
although sadly, fewer and fewer, and the presence of their children and their
children’s children, and, yes, even their children’s children’s children, is a
potent demonstration of the exponential power of survival.
And so we come together and gather alone, moved by our
resolve – a resolve that like a stone, is formed by the pressure of memory and
the weight of sorrow, a resolve that moves us each year to come to this place,
to follow the cadence of the days and the course of the calendar. Today, we will remember and we will honor
and we will mourn.
And this year, among the many whom we mourn privately, as a
community we recall the loss of two people who were so important to this
gathering. Vladka Meed, who along with
her beloved husband, Ben, was a driving force behind the move to remember. Her
own conduct in the Warsaw Ghetto, 70 years ago, was an inspirational example of
courage and action. And we remember Mayor
Edward I. Koch, who did so much for this city and who, at this commemoration 31
years ago, conceived of the idea that became the Museum of Jewish Heritage.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)